Ecrimesa Group
  • EnglishEnglish
    • Deutsch Deutsch
    • Français Français
    • Español Español
  • Home
  • Company
    • About Us
    • History
    • Facilities
    • Quality
    • Commitments
    • Meet our team
  • Services
    • Investment Casting
    • MIM (Metal Injection Moulding)
    • Machining
    • Additive manufacturing
  • Industries
    • Automotive
    • Aeronautical
    • Health
    • Defense
    • Other sectors
  • Downloads
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Additive Manufacturing
  • COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS of MIM vs FDM vs BINDER JETTING

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS of MIM vs FDM vs BINDER JETTING

by Ecrimesa Group / Tuesday, 27 July 2021 / Published in Additive Manufacturing, Technological Comparative

The use of MIM technology has experienced exponential growth over the last decades, establishing itself as the most important technology in the manufacturing processes of metal parts. However, it is possible to find in FDM and Binder Jetting complements to this technology, so they should not be seen only as competitive processes.

MIM (Metal Injection Moulding)

MIM (Metal Injection Moulding) technology is a metal parts manufacturing technology that combines powder metallurgy with plastic injection molding technology. The raw material used is a mixture of metal powder and polymers called feedstock. This material is fed into a mold with the desired geometry by means of an injection machine similar to the one used in the plastic injection molding process. This results in the so-called green part, which is subjected to a chemical-thermal process called desbanderization, the purpose of which is to extract the binder from the part, thus obtaining the brown part. The part is then subjected to the sintering process, so that the particles are joined together to form a high-density metal part with tight dimensional tolerances. MIM technology is suitable for manufacturing parts of complex geometry, small to medium size, and a wide variety of materials are available, such as stainless steels, low alloy steels, soft magnetic, tool steel, ceramics, etc.

Manufacturing MIM technology
MIM technology manufacturing scheme (source: AMPOWER)

FDM Printing

FDM (Fused Deposition Modeling) printing technology, also known as ME (Material Extrusion) or FFF (Fused Filament Fabrication), is the process by which parts are manufactured layer by layer by depositing extruded material (metal powder + polymers) through a nozzle similar to those used in plastic filament printers. This technology can use filament, pellets or rods as raw material and, once the green part is printed, debanding and sintering processes are needed, as in MIM technology, to obtain the final metal part.

Scheme FDM
FDM printing scheme (source: AMPOWER)

Binder Jetting

The manufacturing process of the Binder Jetting technology is based on the deposition of a layer of metal powder on a printing platform and the agglomeration by deposition of polymeric material through a nozzle. Subsequently, polymer curing processes are necessary in each printed layer and, once the printing is finished, the so-called de-powdering process to remove the remaining powder and obtain green parts. Finally, debanding and sintering processes are needed to obtain the metal parts. The debinding process in parts printed by Binder Jetting is less critical than usual, because the amount of binder deposited at the layer junction is minimal. This results in easy removal of the binder from the green part, but at the same time makes the printed green parts fragile and difficult to handle.

Scheme Binder Jetting
Binder Jetting printing scheme (source: AMPOWER)

Characteristics compared between Binder Jetting, FDM and MIM

Although in many articles you can find comparative graphs of technologies where we see overlap between MIM technology and some printing technology, especially Binder Jetting, the reality is that today Additive Manufacturing and MIM are not competitive technologies but complementary. Some fundamental differences between the two technologies are defined below.

Comparison Binder Jetting / FDM / MIM
Comparative graph of metal parts manufacturing technologies (source: AMPOWER)

Manufacturing Speed

Although part developments are much faster in Additive Manufacturing compared to MIM, mainly due to mold manufacturing, post-mold part production becomes faster in MIM technology compared to printing technologies.

Developing Time
Manufacturing speed of FDM technologies VS Binder Jetting VS MIM

Differences in porosity and microstructure

Large porosity associated with printing defects may appear, especially in parts manufactured by FDM. This can lead to lower metal part densities than those obtained by MIM. In addition, the nature of the metal powder used in manufacturing can generate incorrect microstructures that require subsequent heat treatments to improve it.

Sintered part porosity
Sintered part porosity according to manufacturing technology (source: AMPOWER)

Portfolio of materials

MIM technology is much more versatile in terms of the materials available for manufacturing metal parts. Keep in mind that Additive Manufacturing technologies are in the midst of development and their material portfolio is likely to increase as the technology matures. As of today, the portfolio of materials available in printing technologies is limited to stainless steels, some tool steel and few other materials.

Characteristics MIM / FSM / BJ
Characteristics: MIM / FSM / BJ

Surface Finish

Increased roughness in Additive Manufacturing techniques. Necessary secondary finishing improvement operations to compete with MIM. In Ecrimesa Group we guarantee sintered roughness between 0.8 and 1.6 Ra.

Surface finish and roughness
Surface finish and roughness

Design

Possibility of manufacturing more complex parts (hollow parts, bionic geometries, counter-flanges, etc.) and larger parts in Additive Manufacturing technologies.  

Metal piece detail
Source: Metal AM magazine

MIM and Additive Manufacturing technologies working in different market sectors

Although Additive Manufacturing technology is constantly developing and there may be variations, it seems that this manufacturing technology is positioning itself primarily in the medical, industrial and aeronautical sectors.

Potential market & technology
Source: Metal AM Magazine

Mechanical properties

The results of a comparative study of mechanical properties (tensile test) of sintered 17-4PH specimens are shown. Tensile specimens are manufactured according to ISO 2740 Sintered metal materials (excluding hardmetal) according to the different technologies and printers described in the following table.

Technology / Printer Density (g/cc) Hardness (HV10) Ultimate tensile strength Rm (MPa) Yield strength 
Rp0,2 (MPa) 
Elongation 
A (%) 
MIM 7,632969518395,1
FDM Conventional 3D printer 7,532718117496,4
FDM Desktop Metal 7,572748528063,2
Binder Jetting 7,572608707776,7
ISO 22068 
MIM-174PH Sinter 
7,502808006503
Comparative graph of mechanical properties

All the mechanical properties obtained are within the ISO 22068 “Sintered metal injection molded materials specifications” for sintered 17-4PH steel, with the MIM technology showing the best mechanical properties.

Click here to the link:

Metal Injection Molding

What you can read next

What is the best technology for manufacturing metal parts?
Case Study: Desktop Metal Studio System
Metal Injection Molding: advantages and disadvantages

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Proyecto de Innovaciones de Industria 4.0 en Mimecrisa 2021” Cofinanciado por la Consejería de Innovación, Industria, Turismo y Comercio (Gob. Cantabria) y el Fondo Europeo de Desarrollo Regional FEDER El objetivo general del proyecto es avanzar en la transformación digital de MIMECRISA mediante la aplicación de un conjunto de nuevas tecnologías que afectarán a toda la cadena de valor del proceso (para la optimización de su control y mejora continua) al producto (gracias a la reducción de errores y predicción de defectos mediante ML) y al modelo de negocio (facilitando la relación con proveedores/clientes).

La empresa Electro Crisol Metal, S.A. ha sido beneficiaria dentro del programa de SODERCAN SA: "Subvenciones en respuesta a las consecuencias económicas de la guerra de UCRANIA."
De acuerdo con lo dispuesto en el artículo 28.6 la Ley de Cantabria 1/2018, de 21 de marzo, de Transparencia de la Actividad Pública, se publica la siguiente comunicación de retribuciones.

La empresa Mimecri, S.A. ha sido beneficiaria dentro del programa de SODERCAN SA: "Subvenciones en respuesta a las consecuencias económicas de la guerra de UCRANIA."
De acuerdo con lo dispuesto en el artículo 28.6 la Ley de Cantabria 1/2018, de 21 de marzo, de Transparencia de la Actividad Pública, se publica la siguiente comunicación de retribuciones.

La empresa Mecanizados Cantabria, S.L. ha sido beneficiaria dentro del programa de SODERCAN SA: "Subvenciones en respuesta a las consecuencias económicas de la guerra de UCRANIA."
De acuerdo con lo dispuesto en el artículo 28.6 la Ley de Cantabria 1/2018, de 21 de marzo, de Transparencia de la Actividad Pública, se publica la siguiente comunicación de retribuciones.

Flag of Europe

Unión Europea

Proyecto Cofinanciado por el Fondo Europeo de Desarrollo Regional
Programa Operativo FEDER de Cantabria 2014-2020

"Una manera de hacer Europa"

Ecrimesa isotipo blanco

Avda. Parayas 32 ES-39011 Santander. España

Tel.: (+34) 942 334 511
ecrimesa@ecrimesa.es

Company

About us
History
Facilities
Quality
Commitments
Corporate Communications
Contact

Services

Investment casting
MIM
Machining
Additive manufacturing

Industries

Automotive
Aviation
Health
Defense
Other sectors

Downloads

Design Rules and Tolerances - Investment Casting
Design Rules and Tolerances - MIM
Metal Additive Manufacturing guide
MIM Process Guide
See all

© 2021 Ecrimesa. All rights reserved. Legal policies · Privacy policies · Cookies policy · Made with ❤️ by saKudarte

TOP

We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in settings.

Ecrimesa Group
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.

3rd Party Cookies

This website uses Google Analytics to collect anonymous information such as the number of visitors to the site, and the most popular pages.

Keeping this cookie enabled helps us to improve our website.

Please enable Strictly Necessary Cookies first so that we can save your preferences!

Cookie Policy

More information about our Cookie Policy